Patellar Fracture Surgery Performed Autonomously by Residents, Yields Similar Short-Term Outcomes to Surgery Performed by Fellowship-Trained Surgeons
【Abstract】
Surgeries performed solely by residents, without attending supervision, yielded similar short-term outcomes to surgeries performed by fellowship-trained orthopedic surgeons.
The study included 129 patellar fractures and found no significant differences in complications or reoperation rates between the resident and specialist groups.
While residents had longer surgery durations, the overall length of stay was shorter in the resident group.
The findings highlight the significance of surgical autonomy in residency and its role in contemporary surgical education.
The study provides valuable insights into the relationship between resident autonomy and surgical outcomes in the field of orthopedic trauma.
Open reduction and internal fixation are the gold-standard treatment for displaced patellar fractures. The current literature remains inconclusive on the relationship between resident participation in the operating room and optimal patient outcomes. We hypothesize that surgeries performed solely by residents, without attending supervision, can provide similar outcomes to those performed by fellowship-trained orthopedic surgeons, providing new insights into the relationship between resident autonomy and surgical outcomes in the field of orthopedic trauma.
A tertiary trauma center cohort was retrospectively reviewed for all surgically treated patellar fractures between 2015 and 2020. The cohort was divided into 2 groups: patients operated by residents and patients operated by orthopedic trauma specialists. Demographics, surgical parameters, and radiographs were compared between the groups to evaluate complications and reoperation rates, radiographic outcomes (such as hardware failure, or loss of reduction), and clinical outcomes (including residual pain, painful hardware, decreased range of motion, and infections).
A total of 129 patellar fractures were included in the study. Demographics and ASA were similar between the groups. There were no significant differences in complications (p = 0.900) or reoperation rates (p = 0.817), with an average follow-up time of 8 months (SD ± 5.3). Residents had significantly longer surgery duration (p =0.002). However, the overall length of stay was shorter in the resident group (p < 0.001).
The study shows patellar fracture surgery performed by adequately trained residents can provide similar outcomes to those performed by fellowship-trained orthopaedic trauma surgeons. These findings highlight the significance of surgical autonomy in residency and its role in contemporary surgical education.
【Author】
Snir Balziano MD,Eilon Heyman MD,Dan Prat MD
【Journal】
Journal of Surgical Education(IF：2.2) Time：2024-04-27
